Among the small, but highly significant, collection of single-leaf prints amassed by George John, 2nd Earl Spencer (1758–1834), one print has consistently proved controversial. An impression from an etched metal plate, this scene of the Crucifixion bears the ‘impossible’ date of 1430. The date is not the only issue with the impression; stylistically and materially it is unlike any other produced in the fifteenth century. This article examines the impression afresh, recording a variety of oddities and anomalies. It introduces a new piece of physical evidence – the watermark from the paper on which the impression now at the John Rylands Library was printed – before concluding with some observations on the validity and purpose of this extraordinary print.
